Monday, December 7, 2009

Once again, Alderman Wogen is nowhere to be found

Public service can't mean all that much to Alderman Wogen when he misses the last two Committee of the Whole meetings, last two regular council meetings, and the last two Financial Advisory Committee meetings. Someone (i.e. Mayor Povlsen) needs to explain to residents of the Third Ward how they are being represented when Wogen doesn't show up and cannot be reached by email or phone.

Monday, November 30, 2009

"Our View: Absences leave 3rd Ward without representation"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/11/28/78537973/index.xml

Created: Saturday, November 28, 2009 12:27 a.m. CST

Our View: Absences leave 3rd Ward without representation

DeKalb's 3rd Ward had been saddled with enough of a problem when its alderman's recent business dealings with the city were called into question.

But now Victor Wogen has just stopped showing up at city council meetings.

Wogen missed both of November's meetings, as well as a special meeting between the city council and the Finance Advisory Committee. When the Daily Chronicle tried to reach him Tuesday, his cell phone number had been disconnected. He didn't respond to an attempt to reach him via e-mail.

It might have been awkward for him to attend the recent meetings, considering that the council was discussing changes to policies when there's a financial conflict of interest at hand. The changes stem from public projects that Wogen's now-defunct masonry company performed in 2008 by submitting the lowest bid quote to the city. Each of the six projects was less than $20,000, so they didn't require city council action.

Mayor Kris Povlsen said he thinks Wogen should make public statements about his status on the council, but Povlsen said that was Wogen's decision.

But it's clear that the situation can't continue. DeKalb's 3rd Ward needs a representative. Voters elected Wogen. If he continues to miss council meetings, then he isn't doing his job.

According to city ordinance, any council member who isn't at a meeting without a good reason can be fined. Povlsen said city officials might need to take action in the near future, and that should happen as soon as possible.

Wogen is certainly not the first public official to face controversy. This state has a long list of officials that have been under fire for many reasons. But most of them still performed their duties. Some resigned. Doing nothing is the worst option. The 3rd Ward deserves better than that.

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

"City to look into Wogen's absences"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/11/24/59695643/index.xml

Created: Tuesday, November 24, 2009 10:37 p.m. CST

By ELENA GRIMM - egrimm@daily-chronicle.com

City to look into Wogen's absences

DeKALB – Along with taking action to prevent business dealings with a city employee or elected official from going unnoticed, the city council may be taking action regarding an alderman's absences from recent meetings.

Third Ward Alderman Victor Wogen missed both regular city council meetings in November, plus a special meeting between the city council and the Finance Advisory Committee.

Wogen's absence on Monday was publicly noted during the meeting by both members of the public and by a fellow alderman, but the council did not further discuss his absence.

Mayor Kris Povlsen said Tuesday that he has been in contact with the 3rd Ward alderman as recently as a week ago and that Wogen is making some personal decisions. Povlsen said he thinks Wogen needs to make some public statements about his status on the council, but noted that was Wogen's decision.

If that wasn't done in the near future, Povlsen said city officials would have to take some action.

Wogen's cell phone number was disconnected when the Daily Chronicle attempted to reach him Tuesday. Wogen did not immediately reply to an e-mail seeking comment.

According to city ordinance, any council member who isn't at a meeting without a good reason can be fined. It's up to the members present at the meeting to determine what constitutes as an adequate reason for missing.

Alderman on Monday did discuss making changes to policies when there's a financial conflict of interest at hand – proposed changes that stem from public projects that Wogen's now-defunct masonry company performed in 2008 by submitting the lowest bid quote to the city.

Because each of the six projects was less than $20,000, they didn't require city council action, according to state statute.

Revisions to city policy, which follow state law, passed on first reading Monday and will be up for a final vote Dec. 14. If approved, those changes would give the city council more power over the purse strings.

Before voting, several amendments were made to the ordinance to grant the city council more power.

Not only will the council have a say when elected officials have a financial interest, but all city employees who have a business interest with the city that is "above and beyond their normal job" would be subject to the same limitations, City Manager Mark Biernacki said.

The council also wants the final say on all purchases exceeding $10,000 – regardless of whether an elected official or employee is involved. And any contracts between $1,500 and $10,000, in which an elected official or employee is financially involved, would require council approval.

Giving council authority on smaller purchases will slow government, Biernacki said.

"I respect council's wishes but I think it's a mistake in the long run," he said. "Certainly there was a desire – which I support – to limit council involvement in city work, but to go one step farther and limit the city manager's spending authority will result in slowing down of city business and normal day-to-day operational issues."

Povlsen said he was pleased with the direction new policies are going.

The council has taken the task to examine how the city is spending money "very seriously," he said.

Though elected officials wouldn't be banned from doing business with the city, Povlsen said the changes reflect more disclosure and a greater role that the city council will have in making spending decisions.

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

"Protests continue at DeKalb City Council meeting"

http://www.northernstar.info/article/9340/

Published on Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Protests continue at DeKalb City Council meeting
By DEMARCUS ROBINSON

For the second DeKalb City Council meeting in a row, a protest by citizens was held at 5:15 p.m. at the intersection of First Street and Lincoln Highway to protest city ethics.

Citizens came with an array of props such as vacuums and brooms, to illustrate their belief that city ethics need to be cleaned up.

The spark for public outcry came when Third Ward Alderman Victor Wogen was discovered to have entered into a contract with the city, using his privately owned masonry company, Masonry Works LLC.

Wogen was not in attendance Monday night or during the Nov. 9 meeting.

The council discussed the issue of city contracts.

The protestors in attendance agreed with some of the proposed changes that would broaden the scope of who would be under more scrutiny.

“This should not be just limited to aldermen,” NIU graduate student John Duerk said. “It should be all city officials whether elected or appointed.”

Fourth Ward Alderman Brendon Gallagher motioned to have the spending authority of the city manager reduced to $10,000 in an effort to support transparency within the city.

Any city business under $20,000 can be approved by the city manager without going before the council.

City Manager Mark Biernacki appreciated that some sought transparency, though some of the proposed amendments would inhibit day-to-day duties.

“I know people don’t like the fact that I let contracts to Victor Wogen,” Biernacki said.

To limit the city manager to the point that it slows daily activity is not smart, Biernacki said.

Amendments were made to the ordinance, and it will be brought back during the Dec. 14 meeting.

The item on the agenda that took the majority of the council’s energy revolved around Ordinance 09-71, levying taxes for corporate purposes of the city of DeKalb, for the tax year 2009.

The council was presented with several options of what amounts to levy, with all amounts being used to cover mandated pension costs for the police and fire departments.

Under current suggestions, the debt incurred by the city will continue to grow.

“Somewhere down the line, our kids are going to have to come up with this money by 2033,” said Mayor Kris Povlsen.

The council did not come to a resolution as to what the remedy would be, and a motion was passed to bring back the item for a second reading during the Dec. 14 meeting.

Many people in the crowd showed visible signs of disappointment with some of the ideas proposed by the council, which did not sit well with some members, though they understood their displeasure.

“It’s easy to criticize and say no taxes,” Povlsen said. “At some point in time, we’re going to have to expect more help from our citizens to help with this problem.”

Other council members want to see a change in rationale and for residents to keep money within the community.

“We need to encourage residents to spend here, but also need to get rid of relying on sales tax dollars,” said Sixth Ward Alderman Dave Baker.

A public hearing took place during the meeting for four separate establishments seeking to open shops in the downtown district.

Due to the planned location of Euro Tattoo, 128 E. Lincoln Highway, it was recommended that it not be given one of two licenses for downtown because it would be within 500 feet of another establishment, Out On A Whim, 127 E. Lincoln Highway, which is already considered a body art establishment under Illinois state law.

"DeKalb citizens group wants 'clean sweep' of city hall"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/11/24/67211399/index.xml

Created: Tuesday, November 24, 2009 12:02 a.m. CST

By JOHN PUTERBAUGH jputerbaugh@daily-chronicle.com

DeKalb citizens group wants 'clean sweep' of city hall

DeKALB – About a dozen DeKalb citizens gathered Monday evening to collectively call for a "clean sweep" of city government.

Armed with brooms, mops and a vacuum cleaner, members of DeKalb Citizens for Transparency recited chants and marched from First Street and Lincoln Highway to the DeKalb Municipal Building on Fourth Street ahead of the DeKalb City Council meeting.

"We would like open government," group spokeswoman Kay Shelton said. "We would like transparent government. We would like free, open competition for city contracts."

Specifically, the group expressed its discontent with a lack of transparency as it pertains to businesses of elected or appointed city officials getting city contracts for projects.

The DeKalb City Council voted 5-0 Monday on first reading of an ordinance that would give that body more power in authorizing spending when a fellow council member has financial interest in the contract. Aldermen Bertrand Simpson and Victor Wogen were absent from the meeting.

If approved when it is brought back for final reading Dec. 14, contracts in which an alderman is financially involved would require council approval, among other changes to how the city does business.

One suggestion that was supported by aldermen Monday is to include all city employees when it comes to financial ties to a city contract.

The overhaul in financial policy derived from one alderman’s work on public projects in 2008. Wogen, the 3rd Ward alderman, provided the lowest quote on six contracts with the city of DeKalb, winning the maintenance jobs. Because each project was less than $20,000 they didn't require city council action, according to state statute.

"When an alderman gets a contract and people don't know about it, citizens start to lose trust in elected officials," Shelton said. "Openness is the only way to get that trust back."

Members of DeKalb Citizens for Transparency attend city council meetings and get together on an as-needed basis to discuss relevant issues, said John Durek, a political science graduate student at Northern Illinois University who's been involved with the group for about two years.

"I'm interested in being an active citizen," Durek said. "It's not something we should just talk about; it's something we should do. The city was never going to discuss this issue of contracts for aldermen until our group brought it up."

Lynn Fazekas, former DeKalb mayoral candidate, said that she isn't simply against city officials doing private work with the city in all circumstances, but that she just wants more disclosure and transparency when it does happen. As it stands, she said, the problem is that independent local businesses might be discouraged from submitting bids on projects if they believe a city official's business will be awarded the contract because of favoritism.

• Daily Chronicle reporter Elena Grimm contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Sunday, November 22, 2009

"Commission has gone astray"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/11/20/59276787/index.xml

Created: Friday, November 20, 2009 10:57 p.m. CST

Letter: Commission has gone astray

To the Editor:

With former Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin saturating the media last week promoting her book “Going Rogue,” the title of the book struck a very familiar chord with me. Most notably, due the recent discussions of a committee sanctioned by the Mayor Kris Povlsen and the city of DeKalb.

In case you missed it, the DeKalb Citizen’s Community Enhancement Commission (CCEC) at its Sept. 21 meeting spent a great deal of time discussing ways to silence citizens who choose to express their opinions on issues affecting DeKalb though the media (story comments). Quoting now from the official meeting minutes:

“It was suggested that the CCEC speak to the Daily Chronicle to see what can be done regarding untruths and personal attacks on the city and its employees.”

The membership of this committee has chosen to classify the public’s disagreement as misinformation. What are they threatening to do? Boycott the Chronicle’s advertisers? Sue the bloggers? Put duct tape over our mouths? The purpose of the committee is to enhance the community, not silence its citizens or the media.

The official minutes also mention a comment by committee member Brad Pietens, who said “i tmight not be a good idea to let the Chronicle know the bloggers are affecting the city.” Committee member Cohen Barnes also stated “there are not enough people countering these bloggers.”

The official minutes show committee members that were present for this discussion were Chairman Tom Matya, Barnes, Susan Johnson, Mike Mooney, Pietens, Paul Rasmussen and Lisa Small.

It also should be noted that committee member Johnson, representing herself as a CCEC member in front of the DeKalb City Council on Nov. 9, proceeded to make, what I believe, was a very distasteful comment about our Native American community. Her exact quote was: "I think I can beat everybody because I've been here. My family chased the Indians out of Afton Township”

I found this to be in bad taste.

I don’t believe these CCEC members are faithfully engaged in the specified purpose of this committee, and I call upon the members of the committee to resign their positions. In the event that they do not, I call upon Mayor Povlsen, who continually advocates transparency in government, to dissolve the membership of this committee immediately.

Mark Charvat
DeKalb

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Friday, November 20, 2009

"City contracts with aldermen on agenda"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/11/19/12611133/index.xml

Created: Thursday, November 19, 2009 11:45 p.m. CST

By ELENA GRIMM egrimm@daily-chronicle.com
City contracts with aldermen on agenda

DeKALB – The city council Monday is expected to make changes to financial policies that relate to aldermen doing business with the city.

An ordinance will be presented that gives the city council more power in authorizing spending when a fellow council member has financial interest in the contract. Contracts between $1,500 and $20,000, in which an alderman is financially involved, now will require council approval.

Another change caps the total amount an alderman – or his or her business – can receive in one year at $25,000.

Unrelated to an alderman's financial interest, another change proposes that the city manager be the sole authority on purchases between $10,000 and $20,000, whereas department heads currently can make such purchases. The idea behind this is to keep control centralized and reduce potential problems, City Manager Mark Biernacki said Thursday afternoon at a news conference.

The overhaul in financial policy derived from one alderman’s work on public projects in 2008.

Third Ward Alderman Victor Wogen provided the lowest quote on six contracts with the city of DeKalb, winning the maintenance jobs. Because each project was less than $20,000 they didn't require city council action, according to state statute.

Also on Monday, the DeKalb City Council is expected to respond to an agreement that gives Target Corp. a tax break on its DeKalb distribution center after the company failed to meet required employment levels.

At the last city council meeting, it was suggested to give a partial abatement to the company rather than ask for all tax dollars back. The partial abatement would use a pro rata approach, given that the company fulfilled 87 percent of employment levels, or 434 employees out of the required 500.

When asked whether staff preferred no abatement or a partial abatement, Biernacki said there was no recommendation, and that it would be up to the council to decide. Target representatives are expected to be at Monday's meeting, he said.

Four public hearings will be held at Monday's meeting on four applications the city has received for its recently created tattoo business license. The four applicants are for Proton Studio, 120 S. Fourth St.; Campus Tattoo, 1022 W. Lincoln Highway; Out on a Whim, 127 E. Lincoln Highway; and Euro Tattoo, 128 E. Lincoln Highway.

However, city law doesn't allow two body art establishments within 500 feet of one another, and not more than two in the downtown area. Out on a Whim and Euro Tattoo are too close, and those two businesses, along with Proton Studio, are all proposed for downtown locations.

The council is expected to grant licenses at the Dec. 14 meeting.

Also on the agenda:

• A consideration to hire a consulting group to perform an analysis on transit needs for the Voluntary Action Center, using Federal Transit Agency funds.

• A consideration of a snow removal plan for the upcoming snow season, which would plow all streets but salt only major thoroughfares.

• A consideration of closing the County Home TIF District because the cost for redevelopment has been fully recovered by the increased increment. If approved, the TIF would be dissolved 13 years early and more than $600,000 would be distributed back to taxing bodies.

• An estimate of the property tax levy is to be received and filed, with a public hearing and final vote made Dec. 14.

If you go

What: DeKalb City Council meeting
When: 6 p.m. Monday
Where: DeKalb Municipal Building, 200 S. Fourth St. in DeKalb

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

"Clean-up DeKalb City Hall” - Novermber 23, 2009

DeKalb Citizens for Transparency
AKA The Mop & Bucket Brigade


PRESS RELEASE

What: “Clean-up DeKalb City Hall” Rally and March*

When: Monday, November 23, 2009, 5:15-6pm

Where: Begins at Lincoln Highway and First Street; ends at City Hall

“Attention, attention…we need a clean-up in aisle…I mean, Ward Three.”

In the wake of the Wogen–Biernacki downtown construction contract scandal, local city watchers demand reform in how their city operates. Now that our public officials have had weeks to discuss the matter (and multiple citizens have made great suggestions), it is time members of the Council adopted new measures to guarantee that corruption never gains a foothold in our government. Note: This scandal has caught the attention of the Sunlight Foundation, a think tank and investigative organization in Washington, DC.

*Armed with personal vacuums, mops and buckets, spray cleaners and rags – all for symbolic protest, city watchers will rally at the corner with signs and a megaphone (for “speak-outs”) to inform people sitting in their cars at the stoplight about unscrupulous local politics. Then they will chant while marching eastward on Lincoln Highway, turn right at Fourth Street, and proceed to the Municipal Building to rally before the Committee of the Whole meeting.


-END-

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

"DeKalb Commission should focus on city business, not newspaper's online comments"

http://www.northernstar.info/article/9191/

DeKalb Commission should focus on city business, not newspaper's online comments

By THE EDITORIAL BOARD
Last updated on 11/16/2009 at 10:02 p.m.

DeKalb’s Citizens’ Community Enhancement Commission decided during its September 21 meeting that the city needs to talk with DeKalb’s local newspaper, the Daily Chronicle.

According to the minutes from the meeting, the reasoning behind this talk is to limit the “untruths and personal attacks on the City and its employees.” The committee also discussed having members of the community and members of the committee write letters to the Chronicle “to counteract this and look to the Chronicle for accountability.”

The Citizens’ Community Enhancement Commission is concerned that those who comment on the Chronicle’s Web site will sway the vote of council members on city projects. However, couldn’t the city government monitoring comments and peoples’ opinions on city business be considered unlawful based on the First Amendment? When citizens are stating their personal opinion on a matter discussed by the city council, the City of DeKalb should not have the authority to say their opinion is wrong by asking the Chronicle to take down a comment that it does not like. The Chronicle has guidelines for those who are posting, one of which is “do not post potentially libelous statements or damaging innuendo.”

The city should have trust in the Chronicle and its ability to monitor comments. Committee member Lisa Small said “the Chronicle may be motivated to take action if they are pressured by their advertisers,” according to the meeting minutes.

Chapter 65 of DeKalb’s Municipal code, titled “Citizens’ Community Enhancement Commission,” states that the commission was created to “prepare, analyze, recommend and implement a plan to further enhance the appearance, quality of life and reputation of the city of DeKalb.”

The comments on the Chronicle seem trivial when the city is looking at a tremendous shortfall in revenue. At the DeKalb City Council meeting on Oct. 27, Rudy Espiritu, DeKalb assistant city manager, projected the city might see a $2 million to $3 million shortfall in revenue.

Perhaps the commission should have used its time to discuss possible ways to help the city find a way out of said shortfall. Even discussing projects able to be put on hold to save the city money would have been more beneficial.

The city should have greater concerns than anonymous people screaming at each other on the Internet.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

From insensitivity to subversion of the U.S. Constitution...

...we simply can't let this slide.

During the council meeting last night, Susan Johnson, the owner of American Title Guarantee, introduced herself by making a disturbing comment with regards to her family's history in the area: "I think I can beat everybody because I've been here - my family chased the Indians out of Afton Township so many years ago that, you know, we've just been here forever." This is beyond offensive - it's morally despicable, really. If you watch the video clip and listen very closely, you'll hear people in the audience laughing, as if genocide is a laughing matter. Ms. Johnson is also a member of the Citizen's Community Enhancement Commission, a commission that has discussed ways to suppress local dissent because the monied interests are afraid of those who question and / or oppose their agenda. So much for the Freedom of Speech.

If you find any of this upsetting, click here and send her a personal message. She needs to hear from you.

Where in the world is Alderman Wogen?

Slick Vic didn't make it to the council meeting last night. Hmmm. This is interesting since there was a 'good government' rally downtown and then a march to City Hall. Do you think that he stayed home so as to not further humiliate himself? I mean, if he knew about the events that were planned earlier, it's conceivable that he didn't want to face more public criticism - especially in front of so many local business leaders.

"Citizens protest DeKalb governmental practices"

http://www.northernstar.info/article/9061/

Citizens protest DeKalb governmental practices
By DEMARCUS ROBINSON

Monday night, prior to the DeKalb City Council meeting, a group of 13 concerned residents organized a protest of DeKalb governmental practices.

The protest took place at the intersection of First Street and Lincoln Highway, and once the protest was over the participants attended the city council meeting and voiced their opinions.

The group could be considered a watch dog group.

“We call ourselves a group of city watchers, and we’ve been involved in watching the actions of city government for quite some time,” said DeKalb resident Lynn Fazekas.

The members of the group put together a flier with a list of seven demands that they believe would improve government operations.

At the center of the demands was a commitment to be made to the highest standards of ethical conduct at all departments and levels of city government.

Another point of concern regarded the actions of Third Ward Alderman Victor Wogen and called for the immediate termination of all staff involved in his Masonry Works employment arrangement with the city.

Wogen was not present at the city council meeting.

Fazekas said the point of critical mass was finding out that aldermen and city employees do extra work without the citizens knowing about it.

Another point of interest of the group was censorship.

“The latest revelation is that the Citizens Community Enhancement Commission actually talked about at their Sept. 21 meeting, pressuring a local daily newspaper to remove online comments that are unflattering to the city,” Fazekas said.

There was also concern raised about how decisions are made.

“It’s problematic because the city manager gets to decide when there are expenditures under $20,000,” said John Duerk, NIU graduate student.

Some feel that more scrunity is a possible solution to these concerns.

“I think that there needs to be more disclosure in how the city does business,” Duerk said.

The Freedom of Information Act is a way for citizens to gain access to government information, but some feel that it does not do enough.

Duerk feels that strides have been made, but that citizens should be provided with whatever documents that they request, and not just what officials want to provide. Some protestors want the city officials to realize change in procedure is needed because the economy is changing.

“I feel they need to realize that it’s time to adapt,” said Mac McIntyre, a DeKalb resident. “The climate has changed, the economy has changed; they can’t continue with a plan that we need to borrow money to compete.”

The fact that there has been a warning of a possible $2 million or $3 million shortfall is a wake up call, McIntyre said.

McIntyre also believes that a citizen review board would be a good idea to have in place to overlook things such as spending.

There are individuals who may call the protesters “whiners and complainers,” Fazekas said, but she said they view themselves as otherwise.

“On this list of demands you will not find a complaint,” Fazekas said. “You will find ideas for action that will lead to better city government, which is all we want.”

Many of the protestors said that the protest came together rather quickly, but that it is not specifically a one-time deal.

“I could see us doing it again, maybe in a couple of weeks,” Fazekas said. “We have to wait and see how the situation turns out.”

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

"City government needs major reform"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/11/03/78289092/index.xml

Tuesday, November 3, 2009 9:03 p.m.

To the editor:

As both a concerned citizen and a student of political science, I frequently question the motivations of political actors while analyzing the operation of governing institutions. If you have been following the newspaper and blogs in recent years, then you know that some local officials have serious credibility problems. Personally, I find it all rather unsettling because political corruption starts somewhere, and public confidence plummets when citizens feel they cannot trust the individuals elected and appointed to govern on their behalf.

Amidst the discussion of city contracts being awarded to sitting alderman, City Manager Mark Biernacki defends choosing Alderman Wogen’s now-defunct, private company on the grounds that he saved us money. This morally bankrupt rationalization leaves me with two questions. First, if he truly cares about the taxpayers, then why isn’t his primary concern the manner in which the city conducts its business? Secondly, why isn’t he concerned about who the city conducts its business with?

The more I think about this whole ordeal, the more I am convinced that projects of this nature should always be examined by the entire council. Honestly, I do not trust the city manager to make good decisions with his existing unilateral, discretionary expenditure power. Furthermore, I believe that it is far too convenient that Alderman Wogen ran for office and won in 2007 when these 2008 contracts involve work inside the Third Ward.

Since we live in a democracy, we deserve better from our city leaders. We should not accept their exercises in poor judgment and the weak excuses that follow – excuses that are geared toward placating voters, not resolving the larger problems. We must firmly insist upon a change of actors as well as the normative behavior that permeates City Hall. Biernacki and Wogen should take the only respectable course of action at this point: resign immediately. Moreover, a new policy should be enacted that not only constrains the city manager’s ability to act in a unilateral capacity, but also promotes greater disclosure. Please e-mail and call your alderman to demand reform today.

John A. Duerk
DeKalb

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Sunday, November 1, 2009

"Our View: The appearance of impropriety"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/10/31/81913490/index.xml

Saturday, October 31, 2009 12:14am

The term "appearance of impropriety" has become such a cliche in today's society that it has its own Wikipedia entry, attributing the phrase to Biblical origins. Its versatility toward 21st-century parlance was proven again earlier this year when an "American Idol" contestant with personal ties to the show's management company was ousted to "avoid the appearance of impropriety."

The narrow path between what's right and what's legal can conceal a gulf of potential misconduct. That's why it's not enough for public officials to simply avoid improper conduct, but also its very appearance. Everyone from St. Paul to Simon Cowell has understood this well-worn concept. Unfortunately, it seems to have escaped the notice of DeKalb City Manager Mark Biernacki and 3rd Ward Alderman Victor Wogen.

Biernacki said when he awarded six work bids in 2008 to a masonry company owned Wogen, he did not consider it "an issue worth making a mention of." The bids totaled $52,880, but because each was less than $20,000, they did not require authorization by the city council; they merely needed Biernacki's approval.

Biernacki said the intentions were good, to do the work at the lowest cost and within the law. But it should have been clear to anyone that additional due diligence was required. If Biernacki was going to hire one of his bosses, he should have made sure the others knew it.

Most of Wogen's peers on the city council say they were not aware he owned the now-defunct Masonry Works LLC. But one alderman did know it, and that, of course, is Wogen. He, even more than Biernacki, should have had the common sense to tell his fellow aldermen when he was bidding on projects and when his company was awarded the work.

That sort of voluntary openness leads to good government. The opposite is true when officials stay mum on clear conflicts of interest, so long as everything is legal. That environment encourages a widening of that gulf between what's right and what's legal, a gray area that tends to breed waste and corruption if allowed to fester.

Now, DeKalb officials are looking to strengthen disclosure rules. That's a good idea, but one that would not have been necessary if someone had simply stood up and said, "Oh, by the way ..."

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Email sent to City Hall

The following public officials were sent this message: the Mayor, all seven of the aldermen, the City Clerk, the City Manager, and the Director of Public Works.

Subject: "Welcome to Wogen Watch!"

Dear Officials at City Hall,

After the 'smear mailer' debacle amidst the 2007 Election, we all knew it was only a matter of time before Alderman Wogen sparked another controversy for himself. For that reason, it is imperative that Wogen Watch continue providing local citizens with the information they need to know about the unscrupulous behavior of the individuals representing them. The more that has been uncovered over the past two and a half years, the more an unsettling pattern reveals itself. We deserve better representatives in the City of DeKalb, and Wogen Watch is determined to help bring that about by posting new articles, documents, video, and commentary that informs the public.

Please drop by the blog to read the latest post when you have a moment.

Here is a recent post that you might find of interest: "More details on how Wogen failed to pay his workers".

The countdown to the 2011 Election is on!

Sincerely,

Wogen Watch

*Wogen Watch is delighted to report that there have been thousands of visits to the blog with some visitors spending more than an hour reading dozens of posts.

"Policies vary to avoid conflict of interest"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/10/27/52661539/index.xml

October 27, 2009 10:20pm

By ELENA GRIMM - egrimm@daily-chronicle.com

Neighboring communities run the gamut when it comes to allowing elected officials to be contracted for city work.

In Belvidere, the practice is outright prohibited.

“It’s a conflict of interest,” said Belvidere City Finance Manager Pat Chamberlin, adding that she believes it’s an unwritten rule rather than something that’s set down in local law.

In Rochelle, two council members are paid on-call firefighters, who supplement the full-time fire department when needed. And another council member is a local real estate agent and developer whose business often brushes shoulders with city affairs, Rochelle City Manager Ken Alberts said.

“Whenever there were any issues or agenda items that related to his clients or his development, then, of course, he abstained from the voting,” Alberts said.

DeKalb City Council members are considering revising financial policy after it was disclosed that 3rd Ward Alderman Victor Wogen’s company was awarded six contracts totaling $52,000 in 2008. Currently there are no restrictions or requirements for disclosure on city officials winning contracts for public projects. The city is considering creating a more transparent process.

Rochelle follows similar guidelines as DeKalb when it comes to spending authority. Expenditures under $20,000 – such as those awarded to Wogen’s company – can be approved by the city manager without city council action.

But Rochelle’s city manager purposefully discloses aldermanic business ties with the city to other officeholders to avoid an appearance of conflict of interest.

“Part of my responsibility is to make sure they’re aware of it,” Alberts said.

Sycamore also defers to state law when it comes to local policy. However, there hasn’t been an instance of an alderman wanting to do work for the city that City Manager Bill Nicklas can recall.

“Obviously, the topic invites judgments about what is legal, but also what may be the appearance of a conflict,” Nicklas said. “Outside of the legal parameters, there’s always that question that the elected body has to determine.”

Nicklas said if the question ever came before Sycamore, “I would think that our elected officials would make that disclosure.” And Nicklas said if he was aware of an alderman having business interests in a project, he would disclose that information himself.

On county projects, DeKalb County Board members can also bid on a project, win the competition, and abstain from voting if the project comes before the board.

But county policy prohibits a county board member from being privy to the bidding process.

“The person who bids could not have participated in structuring the bid and could not know anything other than what’s been publicly released about the bid request,” DeKalb County Administrator Ray Bockman said. “They couldn’t use their position on the county board to gain advantage of the bidding process.”

Local policy differs greatly from city to city because each municipality is given its own discretion on how it spends money, as long as it’s within the law.

The Illinois Municipal League, a statewide lobbying and educational organization for municipalities, advocates for keeping decision-making local. The IML defers to state statute when it comes to city contracts with aldermen.

Larry Frang, executive director of IML, said that interpreting that statute would require a legal opinion. He said the IML urges city officials to talk with an attorney to make sure they’re in compliance with the law. But the league has no stance on the ethical implications.

“There’s a lot of things we might give people advice on; conflict of interest is not one of them,” Frang said.

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

More details on how Wogen failed to pay his workers

If you follow the links below, then you can read the official correspondence about Alderman Wogen failing to pay his employees prevailing wages while in charge of Masonry Works, a company that is now defunct because it was involuntarily dissolved by the state.

[Note: After clicking the link you can click the body of the letter to magnify it.]

Someone who violates the law like this should never receive contracts from the City of DeKalb - regardless of how low his quotes (bids) are, nor should he be allowed to operate anywhere inside the city limits. This is our community and it's time we took it back from unscrupulous officials.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

"More disclosure likely when aldermen do business with the city"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/10/26/93657407/index.xml

By ELENA GRIMM - egrimm@daily-chronicle.com

DeKALB – City council members will continue to be allowed to do business with the city, but there will likely be greater awareness when that happens.

During their regular Committee of the Whole meeting Monday night, aldermen made several suggestions about the type and amount of disclosure they think is needed. But overall sentiment was that having business-savvy elected officials do business with the government they serve is not a concern if the process is legal and saves money.

“I don’t think we would be doing ourselves a service to the community to say to council people, ‘You can’t do business with the city,’” 6th Ward Alderman Dave Baker said.

“We’ve had several business people in this community who have served on this council in the past and continue to serve on this council that have provided some valuable input,” 7th Ward Alderman Brent Keller said.

The discussion derived from one alderman’s work on public projects in 2008. Third Ward Alderman Victor Wogen won six out of eight contracts with the city of DeKalb because he provided the lowest quote for the maintenance jobs.

The six projects that the now-defunct Masonry Works LLC won totaled $52,880, though each individual project cost less than $20,000. Expenditures less than $20,000 don’t require authorization by the city council but can be approved by the city manager, according to state and city law.

When he learned of the connection Wogen had to these downtown repairs, Mayor Kris Povlsen called for more transparency and asked that the council revise its financial policy to either limit or prohibit an alderman doing business with the city.

He said Monday that any amount of work that a city council member is party to – regardless of cost or accordance to state law – should be disclosed to the city council beforehand.

Fourth Ward Alderman Brendon Gallagher suggested that aldermen submit an annual disclosure statement that would list all business information for that person.

Other suggestions involved tweaking financial and purchasing policies for better clarification.

After the discussion, several residents complained of mistrust and mismanagement.

“Why is it a matter of how much money we save rather than how we do business?” asked John Duerk, a political science graduate student. “Even if it’s not illegal, it certainly is an exercise in poor judgment.”

Kay Shelton said she was concerned with what she said was an investigation by the Illinois Department of Labor on Wogsn’s Masonry Works. She said residents she has spoken with are “disgusted,” but not surprised by the activity between an alderman and the city.

But aldermen supported how the rules are generally written, with room for improvement.

“Should there be certain prohibitions? Perhaps. I’m not aware on my time on the council of any inappropriate behavior in any sort of way,” 1st Ward Alderman Bertrand Simpson said. “I’m quite happy with the way the rules are currently.”

What’s next?

Revisions to the purchasing policy and financial administration policy, including disclosure requirements, will be presented to the DeKalb City Council at a future meeting.

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.

"DeKalb City Council discusses aldermen's city contract rights"

http://www.northernstar.info/article/8769/

DeKalb City Council discusses aldermen's city contract rights
By AMANDA PODGORNY

DeKalb City Council aldermen voiced their opinions on limiting aldermen’s ability to work on city contracts during Monday’s committee meeting.

This comes after DeKalb Mayor Kris Povlsen and City Manager Mark Biernacki received several questions regarding Third Ward Alderman Victor Wogen’s involvement in city contracts.

Wogen’s company, Masonry Works, LLC, held six contracts with the city during the summer of 2008 to do masonry work in the downtown area. Wogen’s company is not currently operating.

“There has been significant discussion about this throughout the city,” Biernacki said.

There is no ordinance banning aldermen from doing business with the city, as long as certain procedures and state statutory limitations are followed, City Attorney Norma Guess said in an Oct. 20 press release.

The state statute states that projects less than $20,000 can be administratively approved by the city manager without council action. If the project does happen to go to an alderman, no current local or state law states he must disclose his ownership in the company to the council or citizens of DeKalb.

None of Wogen’s projects were more than $20,000, and according to the press release, the total of the six separate projects was $52,880.

Biernacki suggested two options to the aldermen.

“We can out-right ban it or perhaps require there be more control, limitations and disclosure,” Biernacki said.

First Ward Alderman Bertrand Simpson does not believe there is a need for change in the city’s code.

“I myself am happy with the way things are,” Simpson said.

Sixth Ward Alderman Dave Baker stated that he has been the president of Copy Services, 1005 W. Lincoln Highway, for 31 years and said his experience as an entrepreneur has offered a unique point of view to the council.

“We want the diversity on the council,” Baker said. “I don’t think that we’d be doing a favor to the community by saying [aldermen can’t] do business with the city.”

Baker was weary of the timing of this proposed change and said it would only be fair to consider this change 180 days before the next local election so that this would only impact aldermen.

“[The council] shouldn’t try and change this mid-stream,” Baker said.

Fourth Ward Alderman Brendon Gallagher said aldermen holding contracts with the city can be a blurry issue.

“Can aldermen do business with the city?” Gallagher said. “You are walking a very fine line.”

Gallagher suggested aldermen be required to fill out annual disclosure that lists aldermen’s businesses and any other business-related information, to be filed around November or December.

Baker suggested a similar idea that would require the city to find out if an alderman or city official have a part in a company before “cutting a check.”

“The city would not cut a check without knowledge of a council member owning a company,” Baker said.

Biernacki will take the aldermen’s suggestions, and this issue will be brought back to the council at a later time.

Monday, October 26, 2009

"Aldermen: Wogen's masonry work went unnoticed"

http://www.daily-chronicle.com/articles/2009/10/23/65661752/index.xml

October 23, 2009 11:55pm

By ELENA GRIMM - egrimm@daily-chronicle.com

DeKALB – Those who work closely with Alderman Victor Wogen on city business say that they were unaware his masonry business had won multiple contracts, valued at more than $50,000.

It was legal for the city to award the contracts to the alderman, but fallout has prompted city officials to consider revising DeKalb's financial policy, possibly to exclude or limit elected officials from doing business with the city. The city council is expected to discuss a revised policy Monday at its regular meeting.

The contracts went over the heads of Wogen's fellow aldermen, who say they don't often talk about each other's business – literally.

The now-defunct Masonry Works LLC won contracts on six projects in 2008 that totaled $52,880. Work included tuckpointing, weatherproofing and other repairs to exterior walls of downtown buildings that had been exposed from demolition projects.

Each project individually cost less than $20,000. Expenditures less than $20,000 don’t require authorization by the city council but can be approved by the city manager, according to state and city law.

Private business

Since Wogen's former masonry business has been brought to light, "we're learning more than we might have known before," 6th Ward Alderman Dave Baker said.

What was known before wasn't much.

Aldermen said they don't often discuss their livelihoods with each other. Most of the aldermen interviewed for this story said that, although they may know the type of work colleagues do, specifics about employers are unknown.

"There are no informal council meetings where we talk about our daily lives," 1st Ward Alderman Bertrand Simpson said.

Aldermen say they knew Wogen he was in the masonry business, but they did not know his company's name. Wogen said he doesn't know the companies other aldermen work for, either.

Sixth Ward Alderman Dave Baker said he was aware Wogen had bid on projects, but defended the practice, saying it had been lawful and saved money because Wogen offered the lowest price.

"As far as what he bid on or what he didn't bid on, he didn't share that on a case-by-case basis. I knew he bid on a few of them," Baker said. "If he was the low bidder then there's nothing out of the ordinary that would raise an eyebrow or a red flag for any of us."

When Masonry Works worked on about a dozen projects in downtown DeKalb last year – six for the city and the rest for private businesses – Wogen said he would stop at work sites occasionally to see how projects were progressing, but that the work was performed by his employees.

It was a small company before it ran out of business last fall, he said. There weren't any company trucks to accompany workers to job sites, so there were no signs carrying name or his company's name as they worked.

The check registry

Each month, the mayor and council receive the city check registry and it is often 20 or emore pages long. The city council doesn't review the register as a group, but each individual member can take as much or as little time as he likes to run through the books.

Nothing requires the city manager to hand over the detailed financial report, but City Manager Mark Biernacki said that it has been customary to do so for years.

"Most of us, I think, are scanning it for unusual items," 2nd Ward Alderman Tom Teresinski said.

It wouldn't seem unusual to see a check written to a masonry company for repair work.

"Quite frankly, as it relates to the Vic Wogen case specifically, if we went down that (registry), we wouldn't have known that that was his business," Mayor Kris Povlsen said.

Biernacki said that, even though the law was followed, contracting with an alderman was "not anything thought of to be an issue worth making a mention of." He said Friday that he is still researching if there were any cases prior to Wogen's in which an alderman had done work for the city.

Neither Wogen nor Biernacki recalled the specific dates that work began and ended, but it spanned the summer months.

Povlsen was an alderman in 2008 that August, when he was appointed to fill the term vacated by Mayor Frank Van Buer, who died in July 2008. Teresinski filled Povlsen's 2nd Ward seat in September. Current aldermen Ronald Naylor, Brent Keller, Simpson and Baker also were in office in 2008.

Biernacki didn't recall whether Van Buer had been aware of any Masonry Works projects, he said.

Seeing the forest and the trees

Povlsen acknowledged that both as an alderman and a mayor, he hasn't spent a great deal of time going through the check registry.

"Going line item through line item through line item – that to me would be micromanaging," he said. "I have issues that are important on a daily basis related to policy development and all kinds of issues as opposed to how much we spend on two or three hundred checks written in a month."

Simpson stressed that aldermen work part time and that the city has a full-time staff.

"The big-picture issues we're aware of but when it comes to the day-to-day running of the city, aldermen don't always know," he said.

Baker agreed that it doesn't make sense to pay staff only for aldermen to micromanage what staff are paid to do.

Aldermen agreed that having more scrutiny over the check registry is not an adequate way to control who gets paid for what. On Monday, they may decide to require disclosure if an alderman is contracted by the city, limit what work can be done or prohibit that scenario altogether.

They could also ask that more projects come before the city council for approval. Baker said he would like to see the threshold where council action is needed on an expenditure dropped from $20,000 to $10,000.

"The argument is that would slow down the city business too drastically. My position has been let's slow it down," Baker said. "The times have changed. We don't have the money to spend that we might have had years ago."

If you go
What: DeKalb City Council meeting
When: 6 p.m. Monday
Where: DeKalb Municipal Building, 200 S. Fourth St. in DeKalb

Copyright © 2009 Daily Chronicle. All rights reserved.